We’re down to the Top 3 and Ryan says everybody is surprised that Chris Daughtry left last week. Well, if he had read last week’s blog entry, he wouldn’t be surprised. Based on Taylor getting to sing an extra song on the results show, it seems like I nailed last week’s finishing order. Don’t worry, it’s not giving me a big head. I’ve mis-guessed too many to let one week make me think I’m an American Idol expert.
On with the show! Let’s find out who will entertain us from the Kodak Theatre next week. Clive Davis is helping out this week, so song selection shouldn’t be an issue… at least for the first songs.
Elliott Yamin
Elliott doing a rock song should be interesting. Valerie was hopping on the Elliott Yamin Bandwagon this week until she found out he smokes. She’s decided to go with Taylor because he’s not taking care of his voice and is disrespecting his instrument. Can’t say I disagree. I have to admit that this is a good song for Elliott. Clive Davis continues to show his genius. This is really good. It doesn’t sound forced or like he’s trying too much. It might be a BIT karaoke in the sense that he’s not changing it up too much. Valerie thinks he should have opened his arms up some more instead of holding the mic stand the whole time. Is Randy Jackson tied to EVERY single band out there? Hey, Simon agrees with Valerie!!! I actually think that’s really good advice for Elliott. He does need to loosen up a bit. Overall, good, but he didn’t set the bar too high.
Katharine McPhee
An underage girl singing a song performed by a guy who likes underaged girls. Appropriate. Uh-oh! Katharine sounded sick when she was talking with Clive!!! Okay, she doesn’t sound sick now that she’s singing. I don’t even have to look to know that Valerie’s cringing on those high notes. I’m liking this better than Elliott’s performance even though the notes aren’t making me feel it too much. I definitely like the arrangement and the performance factor. Valerie said, “she did a Taylor!” Whoo! Uh-oh, Randy and Paula are getting on the song choice. That’s pretty bad when Clive Davis picked the song! I actually agree with Simon. It wasn’t that bad. Not that great, but not that bad. Valerie thinks, “Simon just wants to get into her pants.”
Taylor Hicks
Taylor doing Bruce Springsteen should work great, but he looks a bit disinterested when Clive was talking about it. Wow! Clive made a personal call to The Boss to let Taylor perform the song! Holy crap! Taylor sang the first 6 words and I got chills. “Oh wow,” was Valerie’s reaction. This is DEFINITELY a Taylor Hicks type of song! Okay, stop dancing with Paula, Taylor. It’s not helping you. Still, this is great. Yeah, I REALLY liked that. Perfect song choice by Clive. Taylor needs to send him a big thank you! Randy and Paula got it right. Simon’s a bit off base. That was more than okay. Yeah, Paula’s drunk.
After the first songs, I have it Taylor, Katharine (barely!), and Elliott. This next song could make it or break it for Katharine and Elliott. Let’s hope the judges picked well.
Elliott Yamin
Elliott’s in Richmond and finding out what song he’s going to sing. Ryan thinks Simon is acting like a child? Has he looked in the mirror or at Paula lately? Ryan’s a dumbass. On with the singing Elliott! The slow song is a nice change from his first song. Too bad Paula picked it. I wonder if she’ll say it was a bad song choice. He’s doing pretty good, but I still don’t feel him cutting loose. He’s better than the first song, so Katharine’s going to have to be better to stay in. Overall, I liked it. Again, not great, but better than the first song. I’m with Randy. Paula thinks he, “pierced the heart.” Interesting. I’m probably somewhere between Randy and Simon on that one. If I had heard that performance on its own, I wouldn’t put him through to the Finals based on that.
Katharine McPhee
“Somewhere Over the Rainbow” is actually a great song for her. Dammit! She’s on the frickin’ floor again. Get up and sing!!! If she stays there the whole song, she’s out. Valerie thinks they have an echo on her. I think I hear it, too. This is definitely a great song for her. It shows her low range and that’s a good thing. I know Valerie’s cringing on this high part, but I think she’s doing good. I’m liking her arrangement of the song. Elliott might be in trouble… even though Katharine’s stayed on the floor. I wish she would stand up and be a bit more animated or “into the song.” That’s a PERFECT ending note for her. And she held the entire note! I agree with Randy, Paula, AND Simon. That was great. Elliott’s in trouble.
Taylor Hicks
You knew Randy was going to pick Joe Cocker for Taylor. No doubt about it. Hey, Randy, did you help Cocker with that song? Just kidding, dog. Again, I’m loving the slow song as a follow-up to the more fast paced he sang first. He’s TOTALLY into this and it shows. Wow! I have so many chills it’s just ridiculous. I feel like I’m watching a seasoned veteran up there on stage. Damn! He’s just absolutely nailing this song! Just the right amount of animation, singing, and passion. Just the right amount of everything. Okay, THAT was the performance of the competition. That makes Elliott and Katharine look like karaoke singers. That was an amazing compliment from Simon and I can’t disagree at all. For that to come from someone who didn’t think Taylor would make it has to mean a lot to Taylor.
Elliott Yamin
Following that performance by Taylor might be a bad thing for Elliott. He’s singing that he believes, but I’m not really believing. He still hasn’t put the passion in the song. At least not as much as Taylor. I’m not sure I wouldn’t hear this if I went to the local karaoke night. Don’t get me wrong, it’s good and all, but this pales in comparison to the performance that preceded it. It was overall okay, but this has been Taylor’s show to this point. Randy and Paula think it was bad song choice. Simon thinks Elliott’s songs won’t carry him through to next week, but does think he’s got a great personality. So, he’s like a blind date? Elliott’s still in trouble, in my opinion.
Katharine McPhee
Katharine’s going old school. She doesn’t want to be compared to anybody who’s current. Let’s see if it works for her. It seems like her type of song, that’s for sure. I wonder if it might be too old, though. She’s too busy looking at where she’s walking. Just walk. And sing. Yep, Elliott’s in trouble, even though Valerie just said, “oh, God” to that last note. I know she doesn’t like Katharine’s high notes, but they’ve seemed to work for her to this point. Based on that, I think she’s through to the next round. Not great, but better than Elliott. Randy wasn’t psyched about it. Paula’s referencing “Somewhere Over the Rainbow,” so that’s not good. I agree with Simon that it would have been better for them to end on their second songs. They’re still just not great at song selection. Interesting given how many weeks they’ve been in the competition.
Taylor Hicks
Taylor seems to have done some of the best song selection in the past out of the three remaining, so let’s see if he makes the gap even larger between himself and the other two. Taylor singing for the Soul Patrol. This could be the nail in the coffin. Out of all the performers that have come and gone on American Idol, I think Taylor is the one who most gets into the music. He’s engrossed in it and that translates to his audience. I’m digging this. I do think he would have been better of if he had ended with his second song, but there’s no doubt that he’s heads and tails beyond anything Elliott and Katharine have displayed. Taylor singing about heart and soul and you believe it! Damn, he’s good! That was putting it all out there on the table and saying, “What?!” That was awesome. Randy’s got a new name for him. It’s “Have a Good Time Funky Taylor.” I think it’s “American Idol.” Another compliment from Simon! You go, Taylor!
Quick Replays
Elliott’s okay. Again, he’s okay. Take three: he’s okay. Funny that they go from Elliott believing to Katharine believing. I believe Katharine more. Katharine’s doing good. Valerie hates those high notes, but oh well. Not great, but not as bad as Elliott. Taylor is awesome, awesome, and AWESOME! That was Taylor’s show the whole way. If he’s not the next American Idol, then America’s got it all wrong.
Taylor, Katharine, then Elliott. See you in Richmond, Elliott.